Revise README for liquid-cooled BLDC motor research

Updated README.md to include detailed research on liquid-cooled small BLDC motors, focusing on internal channel cooling concepts and thermal performance expectations.
This commit is contained in:
2026-04-24 15:36:16 +02:00
committed by GitHub
parent d532519cf2
commit 5d59cc413e
+293 -3
View File
@@ -1,11 +1,301 @@
# Motor Research # Motor Research (Apr 24, 2026)
## Liquid-Cooled Small BLDC Motor (≈30 mm) — Research Sheet
## Focus: Internal Channel / Directed Cooling (Concept B)
---
# 🧠 1. Objective
Design a **high power-density, continuous-duty BLDC motor (~30 mm class)** for EDF/prop aircraft using:
> **Directed internal cooling channels through the stator (not full immersion)**
Goal:
- Maximize **continuous power**
- Maintain **high efficiency at very high RPM (30k–100k)**
- Avoid fluid drag losses from rotor immersion
---
# ⚙️ 2. Core Concept (B)
### Definition
A motor where:
- Coolant flows through **engineered paths inside the stator**
- Heat is removed **directly from windings and core**
- Rotor remains **dry (air-filled cavity)**
---
## 🧩 2.1 Cooling Architecture Types
### A. Axial Channels (through stator stack)
- Holes or ducts aligned with shaft axis
- Coolant enters one end, exits the other
### B. Slot-Integrated Cooling
- Channels embedded near winding slots
- Coolant flows alongside copper
### C. Back-Iron Cooling
- Channels placed in stator back iron
- Lower impact on copper fill, but less direct
---
# 🔥 3. Thermal Model
### Heat Sources
- Copper losses:
\[
P_{cu} = I^2 R
\]
- Core losses:
- hysteresis
- eddy currents
---
### Cooling Mechanism
Convective heat transfer:
\[
Q = h \cdot A \cdot \Delta T
\]
Where:
- \( h \) = heat transfer coefficient (high for liquid)
- \( A \) = channel surface area
- \( \Delta T \) = temp difference
---
## 📊 Expected Thermal Performance
| Coolant Temp | Winding Temp | ΔT | Notes |
|--------------|-------------|----|------|
| 30°C | 40–60°C | ~10–30°C | Moderate cooling |
| 20°C | 35–50°C | ~10–25°C | Strong |
| 10°C | 25–40°C | ~10–20°C | Very strong |
| 5°C | 20–35°C | ~10–15°C | Diminishing returns |
---
# ⚡ 4. Electromagnetic Tradeoffs (Critical)
## ❗ 4.1 Reduced Copper Fill
Channels take space → less copper:
- ↑ Resistance (R)
- ↑ Copper losses
- ↓ Torque per amp
---
## ❗ 4.2 Reduced Iron Cross-Section
Channels remove stator material:
- ↓ Magnetic flux capacity
- ↑ Risk of saturation
- ↓ Maximum torque
---
## ⚖️ Tradeoff Summary
| Parameter | Effect |
|----------|-------|
| Cooling | ↑↑ |
| Resistance | ↑ |
| Torque density | ↓ |
| Efficiency (if optimized) | ↑ overall |
---
# 🌀 5. Fluid Design Considerations
## ✔️ Goals
- Maximize heat extraction
- Minimize pressure drop
- Ensure uniform distribution
---
## ❗ Constraints
### 1. Channel Size
- Too small → high pressure drop
- Too large → weak stator + lost copper
---
### 2. Flow Regime
- Laminar → predictable, less transfer
- Turbulent → better cooling, higher loss
---
### 3. Pressure Drop
\[
\Delta P \propto \frac{L \cdot v^2}{D}
\]
Impacts:
- pump requirements
- system efficiency
---
# 🧲 6. Magnetic Design Constraints
## Saturation Limit
Even with perfect cooling:
- Core saturates at high flux
- Current increase → diminishing torque
---
## Design Implication
You must balance:
- channel placement
- iron thickness
- slot geometry
---
# ⚙️ 7. Mechanical Constraints
## 7.1 Structural Integrity
Channels weaken stator:
- risk of deformation
- vibration issues at high RPM
---
## 7.2 Sealing
Unlike concept A:
- sealing is localized (inlet/outlet)
- not full rotor enclosure
---
## 7.3 Weight
Added:
- coolant
- tubing
- pump
Must not exceed thrust gains
---
# 🚀 8. Performance Expectations
## Compared to Air-Cooled Motor
| Metric | Improvement |
|-------|------------|
| Continuous current | ~1.8–2.3× |
| Continuous power | ~2.5–4× |
| Efficiency | ↑ (if well designed) |
| Peak temp | ↓ significantly |
---
# 🧠 9. Key Design Strategy
## 🔑 Optimize for:
- Minimal disruption of magnetic path
- Maximum contact with windings
- Controlled coolant flow
---
## ❌ Avoid:
- Large voids in stator
- Random channel placement
- Overcomplicated routing
---
# 🧪 10. Recommended Cooling Fluids
| Fluid | Pros | Cons |
|------|------|------|
| Dielectric oil | Safe, good cooling | Viscosity |
| Water-glycol | Excellent heat capacity | Conductive risk |
| Fluorinated fluids | Ideal electrically | Expensive |
---
# ⚡ 11. System-Level Optimization
## Important Shift:
> Cooling allows higher current, but optimal design reduces current
---
### Best Practices:
- Lower KV motor
- Higher voltage supply
- Thicker windings
- Maximize slot fill before adding channels
---
# 🧩 12. Hybrid Enhancement (Best Approach)
Combine:
- Partial channel cooling (B)
- Directed oil spray (controlled A)
Avoid:
- full immersion
---
# 📌 13. Final Engineering Insight
> Concept B does not give “free performance”
It trades:
- electromagnetic efficiency
for
- thermal headroom
---
## 🏁 Conclusion
For ~30 mm EDF motors:
✔ Internal channel cooling is **more viable than immersion**
✔ Enables large continuous power gains
❗ Must be carefully balanced against magnetic losses
---
# 🔍 14. Future Exploration
- Additive manufacturing stators
- Micro-channel cooling
- Slot liner cooling integration
- Oil jet targeting windings only
---
# Motor Research (Jul 20, 2025)
The research for better motor tech. We will be comparing between different kinds of motors in order to gain a better understanding of them. The research for better motor tech. We will be comparing between different kinds of motors in order to gain a better understanding of them.
### Priorities ### Priorities
- **Efficiency**: Current efficiency range (70/87%), goal (90-95%), efficiency is measured in output power (rpm/torque) per watt. - **Efficiency**: Current efficiency range (70/87%), goal (90-95%), efficiency is measured in output power (rpm/torque) per watt.
- **Reliability**: Withstand a long duration of high throttle and extreme conditions of weather. - **Reliability**: Withstand a long duration of high throttle and extreme conditions of weather.
## BLDC vs PMSM ## BLDC vs PMSM
| Feature | **BLDC (Brush-less DC Motor)** | **PMSM (Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor)** | | Feature | **BLDC (Brush-less DC Motor)** | **PMSM (Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor)** |
| ------------------------ | -------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------- | | ------------------------ | -------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------- |
| **Rotor** | Permanent magnets | Permanent magnets | | **Rotor** | Permanent magnets | Permanent magnets |
| **Stator winding** | Trapezoidal | Sinusoidal | | **Stator winding** | Trapezoidal | Sinusoidal |
@@ -20,4 +310,4 @@ The research for better motor tech. We will be comparing between different kinds
<img src="images/bldc.png" alt="BLDC motor" height=300 /> <img src="images/bldc.png" alt="BLDC motor" height=300 />
## PMSM - Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor ## PMSM - Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor
<img src="images/pmsm.png" alt="PMSM motor" height=300 /> <img src="images/pmsm.png" alt="PMSM motor" height=300 />